Is it realistic?

For the primary use of Swordscholar youth program students. Respectful guests are welcome, especially if they have something to teach.
User avatar
Liam Rose the Just
Posts: 17
Joined: Tue Aug 10, 2010 4:19 pm

Is it realistic?

Postby Liam Rose the Just » Thu Aug 12, 2010 7:58 pm

I was curious as to whether this was fairly real, or all theatrics. It sure looks cool.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5wQTg8mq_c&feature=related

User avatar
John Harmston
Site Admin
Posts: 735
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 3:27 pm
Location: Utah
Contact:

Re: Is it realistic?

Postby John Harmston » Thu Aug 12, 2010 8:31 pm

Difficult to say with the sketchy camera work and short length, but it looked better than most of what I've seen.
John Harmston
Senior Instructor - True Edge Academy
HEMA Alliance Forum Admin
Lifetime Member, HEMA Alliance

User avatar
Jonathan Mayshar
Posts: 290
Joined: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:25 am

Re: Is it realistic?

Postby Jonathan Mayshar » Sun Aug 15, 2010 7:03 pm

Hi Liam, glad to see you on the forum.

It depends on what you mean by "realistic." The re-enactors are getting all sorts of relatively realistic experience about what it is like to move in armor, to fight with group tactics, to deal with different types of medieval weapons, etc. I agree with John Harmston: It looks pretty good compared to a lot of what is out there. And John's an armor guy, as you can tell from his avatar.

But it's not a realistic battle. They're all moving too slowly on the attack, and no one is "going for the kill." But of course, the only way you get that kind of realism is for lots of people to die.

I believe that HEMA is most "real," and reenactment is most useful for HEMA, when we don't let fantasy suspend our awareness of the gap between what we can teach and experience with acceptable safety, and what it's like to fight for your life on a field of blood with a broken pike.
Jonathan Mayshar
Kron Martial Arts, Orange County, CA
HEMA Alliance Lifetime Member


Return to “Swordscholar”